Both Are Rated 40 kA – So Why Can’t Type 1, Type 2 and Type 1+2 SPDs Be Used Interchangeably?
A practical guide to selecting the right PV DC surge protective device.
Place two PV DC SPDs side by side:
They look almost the same. The voltage is the same, the number of poles is the same, and both carry the same “40 kA” rating.
When the wrong SPD is selected, the system will usually still power up normally. The status indicator may even remain green. The real difference might not appear until an actual surge, or lightning current, reaches the system.
That is what makes SPD selection tricky: just because it fits does not mean it is correct.
First, What Is the Relationship Between SPD, Type 1, Type 2, and Type 1+2?
SPD stands for Surge Protective Device.
Type 1, Type 2, and Type 1+2 are different SPD classifications. They are not three different names for the same product, and the difference is not simply about which one has a higher discharge current.
What really separates them is the source of the surge, the amount of energy involved, and the test waveform they are designed to withstand.
Primarily intended for partial lightning currents that may enter an electrical installation.
Waveform: 10/350 µs
Key parameter: Iimp
Primarily used for induced lightning surges and transient overvoltages caused by switching operations.
Waveform: 8/20 µs
Key parameters: In, Imax
Combines lightning-current discharge capability with surge-voltage limitation.
Check: Iimp, In, Imax, Up

Type 1 is not simply “a larger Type 2,” and Type 1+2 is not just two labels printed on the same device.
Why Is Type 2 More Common in PV Systems?
In many photovoltaic systems, the most common threat is not a direct lightning strike on the equipment itself, but the transient overvoltage caused by a nearby strike.
PV DC cables are often installed over long distances. During a thunderstorm, these cables can pick up high induced voltages. Inverter operation and system switching can also produce transient surges.
These conditions are normally handled by a Type 2 PV SPD.

That is why Type 2 surge protective devices are commonly installed in PV combiner boxes, on the DC side of inverters, and in other solar DC distribution systems.
But “more common” does not mean “suitable for every project.”
If a building has an external lightning protection system and the required separation distance between the PV array, metal mounting structure, DC cables, and lightning protection system cannot be maintained, partial lightning current may enter the DC circuit.
In that case, selecting an ordinary Type 2 SPD without further consideration may not be enough.
Is Type 1+2 Always Better Than Type 2?
Not necessarily.
A Type 1+2 SPD can handle partial lightning current while also limiting surge voltage for downstream equipment. It is suitable for projects where both lightning-current discharge and equipment-level surge protection must be considered.
But if the system only needs protection against induced surges, a Type 2 SPD may already be sufficient.
The right SPD is not automatically the one with the highest rating or the highest price. It is the one whose protection capability matches the actual risk.
Why Does the Same ATSPV-D40 Series Have Different Versions?
This is exactly why the AITE ATSPV-D40 PV DC SPD series is available in several configurations:
2P / 600 V DC
3P / 1000 V DC
3P / 1500 V DC
3P / 1500 V DC
The ATSPV-D40 3P / 1500 V DC is available in both Type 2 and Type 1+2 versions.
Their model names, voltage ratings, and appearance may be very similar, but they are designed for different protection requirements.
This is also why a request such as “Need 1500 V DC SPD, 40 kA” is usually not enough to complete the selection.
Before confirming the SPD, check:
Asking these questions does not make SPD selection unnecessarily complicated. It prevents a product from looking completely correct on paper while performing the wrong protection task in the actual system.
What Else Should Be Checked When Selecting a PV DC SPD?
Maximum Open-Circuit Voltage
When choosing a 600 V DC, 1000 V DC, or 1500 V DC SPD, consider the maximum string open-circuit voltage at the lowest expected ambient temperature when confirming the SPD’s UCPV rating.
Voltage Protection Level, Up
An SPD does not reduce a surge to zero. It limits the voltage to a level the downstream equipment can withstand. A lower Up generally means less residual voltage, provided the other requirements are correctly matched.
The colder the PV module becomes, the higher its open-circuit voltage can rise.
If the UCPV is selected too low, the SPD may remain under electrical stress during normal operation, which can shorten its service life or cause premature failure.
This is why comparing only the “kA” number is not enough.
The PV DC side must also use an SPD designed for photovoltaic applications: a DC SPD, solar SPD, or PV surge protective device.
AC SPDs and PV DC SPDs may look similar from the outside, but they operate under different power-source conditions. They should not be considered interchangeable simply because their housings look alike.
An SPD and a PV Fuse Do Not Provide the Same Protection
Overvoltage Protection
A PV SPD mainly deals with transient overvoltage and surge energy.
gPV Fuse LinkOvercurrent Protection
A gPV fuse link protects the PV circuit against overcurrent and short-circuit conditions.
One limits overvoltage; the other interrupts fault current.
AITE PV DC SPDs, PV fuse links, and PV fuse holders perform different jobs within the system, but they need to work together as part of a coordinated DC protection solution.
The connection conductors should be kept as short and direct as possible. Long connecting wires or unnecessarily indirect grounding paths can increase the actual residual voltage and reduce the protection performance.
The product parameters may be correct, but poor installation can still weaken the final result.
So, the next time you see two SPDs both marked “40 kA, 1500 V DC,” do not start by asking which one is cheaper.
First check whether one is Type 2 and the other is Type 1+2.I’m Rachel. A big part of my day is explaining PV protection products that look almost identical but should never be swapped blindly.
Hopefully, this helps you avoid one more selection mistake—and helps me receive one fewer message saying: “Rachel, aren’t these two the same?”
Need Help Selecting the Right PV DC Protection?
Share your system voltage, installation position, lightning-protection requirements, and project details. Our team will help you confirm a suitable SPD and coordinated DC protection solution.

